The "bomb" that represent loans "Toxic" made by French local authorities can not be defused only by the creation of a bad bank funded by a tax on banks, say elected socialist.
The Court of Auditors estimated in a report released last week that 30 to 35 billion 160 billion of debt taken out by hundreds of local communities are toxic and that an amount between 10 and 12 billion euros presents a potential risk very high.
She points out that many communities are linked by bonds or derivatives they can not escape that by agreeing to pay an interest rate or a cash payment prohibitive in terms of their financial means.
"The Court of Auditors has denounced the bomb posed by these toxic loans," said Socialist Claude Bartolone, who chairs the committee of inquiry established by the National Assembly on this issue.
Once past an initial period during which interest rates remain low, some public bodies have seen the financial crisis flying rates indexed to parameters such as parity Swiss franc-sterling.
Interest rates are now double-digit streams and strangling local communities.
Maurice Vincent, Socialist mayor of Saint-Etienne, a city severely affected by the phenomenon, initiated a lawsuit against Deutsche Bank and Royal Bank of Scotland, who granted the city for 20 million euros in loans.
"Unconscionable contracts"
Christophe Faverjon, the mayor of Unieux (Loire), a town of 8,500 inhabitants near Saint-Etienne, had contracted in 2007 to 7 million loan to the Franco-Belgian bank Dexia, which 4 million were found toxic.
In his attempts to renegotiate, Dexia has offered to pay 6.47 million euros in compensation, in addition to 4 million, to return to a fixed rate of 3.9% set in the beginning.
The mayor has decided to file a complaint against the bank Dexia for "failure to counsel" and "unconscionable contract."
Claude Bartolone, chairman of the General Council of Seine-Saint-Denis, by borrowing heavily indebted toxic, filed a complaint against three banks – Depfa, Calyon (now Credit Agricole CIB) and Dexia.
The interest rate on the loan made to his community with the German bank Depfa increased from 1.47% to 24.2%.
These local officials welcomed the report of the Court of Auditors.
"This is a very good value, quality, which confirms what we have said for two years," said Maurice Vincent to Reuters."The only problem is that the court does not favor the creation of a bad bank."
The French government has promised to consider the proposal but there is not a priori favorable.
The mayor of Saint-Etienne, however, intends to maintain the pressure because it "will solve the problem many of these loans between 2002 and 2008 with a solution that approaches" the defeasance structure it advocates.
It accounts for that on the balance of power that would create the Commission of Inquiry of the Assembly, which is due to report at the end of the year with legislative and regulatory recommendations.
A TAX ON BANKS?
The Socialist Group of the National Assembly has also set up a working group chaired by Claude Bartolone to establish by law a bad bank.
Alternatives to its creation are indeed considered unrealistic by the leaders of local communities.
Of course, criticizing the banks, which have not sufficiently informed the public of the risks involved.
But these procedures are likely to drag on, with a very low chance of achieving concrete results.
But a solution must be found quickly, the debt crisis that would result in soaring interest rates.
"Raising taxes? It is impossible.No mayor will not want to do and I first, "said Maurice Vincent excluding also reduce the investment of Commons.
Communities could also refuse to pay, but the mayor of Saint-Etienne does not believe in this solution.
"Then the Minister of Communities who will trust the cities and the government should take the initiative to raise taxes as a result, it will not," said he.
It remains, therefore, the bad bank, "a collective solution that would be better for everyone, for mayors, for communities," said Maurice Vincent.
The latter proposes to create a tax on banks to fund 5 to 8 billion euros of losses engender in his loans "toxic".
Maurice Vincent believes that the state will eventually resolve it to preserve the "triple A" of France, a rating that allows it to borrow cheaply in the markets.
"The government will solve the problem before it alters the note of France. The State may take 1 or 2 billion to its charge, communities take their share as well as banks must collectively get out of this case. "